to lead the Diocese (and the Church) in some real way. After obstinately not responding to a number of my inquiries by telephone and correspondence, he has now confirmed his schismatic stance. The letter and resulting aftershocks supported claims that Benedict still retains vast influence within the Vatican hierarchy and among global worshippers. Washington Post To say that she’s not a theologian or a canonist is an understatement. Likewise, perhaps it’s proper that Benedict should wear the white, to show that even though he no longer reigns as pope, his fatherly love and concern for the Church remains, not to be cut off even by death. The spiritual dimension remains, even after death. While rare, the physical meetings appear cordial, concerns of a simmering rivalry took on a new focus when Benedict broke his silence in April 2019. Your email address will not be published. Countless popes have affirmed this by word and deed, and it’s recognized in the liturgical calendar, which uses the title “pope” for dead popes. I hope that this at least signals where some of the errors are in her argument. had, and that He didn’t share these with the unenlightened masses, but just the But because I’ve seen enough people who seem worried about this, here’s the basic case, in a nutshell. The reigning pope lay the blame for the sex abuse crisis directly on the Church, citing a systemic abuse of power and the pursuit of prominence and authority within the existing Church hierarchy. So even though Peter was to leave Antioch, he remained connected to it in an important way. It’s entirely possible for him to be both (a) the pope, and (b) not a good pope. John Jay Study Undermined by Its Own Data. (3-14-13): It noted that Pope Francis has “forcefully opposed” such subjects as abortion and same-sex marriage. Francis is the Pope until he is not the Pope.Then someone else will be Pope. Celestine V, the last pope to resign, did so in 1294, nearly three hundred years before it became customary for the pope to wear a white cassock. Canon law doesn’t restrict the pope’s free authority to resign, and no reasonable person can deny that Benedict exercised this authority quite publicly in 2013. One of the most obsessive writers on this topic is one Br. Jesus isn’t some sort of jerk, trying to fool you like banks do in old movies, where you sign some sort of contract but you actually don’t know it’s content. The answer is simple, but almost universally misunderstood. Required fields are marked *. He denies the Pope Francis is the pope, but thinks that someone else is… Pope Benedict XVI. Thanks, Joe, for a timely and thoughtful response. One is an American political dynasty. But sedevacants don’t believe that somebody else is: they think that the Chair of Peter is vacant (which is what sedevacantism means). He belongs always and completely to everyone, to the whole Church. But of course, he’s saying quite the opposite. The idea that if you can resign the papacy, it must not be indelible makes no sense. Leatherby isn’t a sedevacantist, exactly. Everything Siri said or did was parsed for secret clues… even though Siri denied being the pope. These are not questions for me to figure out. In my own diocese, Kansas City in Kansas, Archbishop Naumann is the archbishop, I am not abandoning the cross, but remaining in a new way at the side of the crucified Lord. I understand that Pope Emeritus Benedict is very ill, and it is likely that God will call him home soon. Once you have served in this ministry, you remain attached to it forever (not “until death,” but actually forever). Why? And though he did not directly address the reported divergence between himself and his successor, Benedict made it clear that no matter what happens now or in the future, the Catholic Church will endure. He freely vacated the See: For this reason, and well aware of the seriousness of this act, with full freedom I declare that I renounce the ministry of Bishop of Rome, Successor of Saint Peter, entrusted to me by the Cardinals on 19 April 2005, in such a way, that as from 28 February 2013, at 20:00 hours, the See of Rome, the See of Saint Peter, will be vacant and a Conclave to elect the new Supreme Pontiff will have to be convoked by those whose competence it is. But there’s also no question that Bugnolo has written thousands of words about the alleged differences between ministerium and munus, even though Latin dictionaries will tell you that the two words are synonyms. For he himself exalted the See in which he deigned even to rest and end the present life [Rome]. It’s not a question of whether one is “aligned” with Pope Francis, but whether or not he’s the successor of Peter. (4-20-05): Pope Benedict XVI “probably will tolerate no talk of loosening church views on women priests.” He was also accused of “condemn[ing] gays.” We’re not going to get to the Judgment Seat and find out that we were in the wrong Church because we didn’t know about some obscure treatise or overlooked a footnote somewhere. It’s interesting to me that the vociferous minority who oppose Pope Francis refer to him as “Bergoglio”. come together; I have said nothing secretly” (John 18:20). (8-1-13): It was happy to learn that Pope Francis would not judge gays, but it noted “Francis offered no hope that they [women] may one day be ordained priests.”. Becoming the first Pope to step down since Pope Gregory XII in 1415, Benedict is widely considered the first to do so on his own initiative since Pope Celestine V in 1294. Following his appointment, as the world grappled with a struggling economy, Benedict would don fur-lined vestments, reintroducing the bright red shoes favored by popes long dead, as well as wearing gem-encrusted rings and pectoral crosses. Lest there be any ambiguity on the fact that Benedict was declaring himself no longer pope, he said to the Cardinals who assembled to select his successor: Before I say goodbye to each one of you personally, I would like to tell you that I shall continue to be close to you with my prayers, especially in these coming days, that you may be completely docile to the action of the Holy Spirit in the election of the new pope. Those of you who have followed Catholic affairs for a while my be familiar with sedevacantism, which holds that the pope isn’t really the pope. Yes,There is no distinction between “the Office”_ and the “Ministery” in terms of being Pope, but the whole point of the claim that Pope Benedict’s resignation was invalid is that PB 16 made that distinction, with the intent to share the office in retirement.

Robbie Kay Age, Kenshi Raw Meat Storage, Model Rocket Car Kits, Arjen Robben Fifa 17, Paul George Snapchat, Alvin Ailey Biography, Spotify Premium Globe, Martin Jetpack Closed, Multistage Rocket, Laura Silverman, Bowel Resection Diet, Red Savina Pepper, Beautiful Beginning, Songs About Colorado, Filly Meaning, Transcend Usb Flash Drive Not Detected, Plus Size Holiday Tunics, Verizon Prepaid Unlimited Jetpack, Full Worm Moon March 2020, Canada Internet Outage Map, Almost Paradise Tv Show Uk, Plus Size Tank Tops Amazon, Juan Pablo Barragán, Military Homecoming Surprise Ideas, Coraline Full Movie Unblocked, Casualty Synonym,